Doubts raised that PA registration will go ahead

Related news

COVID findings must be ‘mandate for lasting change’

NHS Scotland chief named as battle lines emerge

Sceptical response to government’s care proposals

Donald Macaskill: Where is Scotland going?

Briefing: The 5-year plan for NHS, care and science

One precedent, inconsistently applied

© Monkey Business

by Esmé Pringle

Friday 13th October 2023

The chair of the Scottish government’s Personal Assistant (PA) advisory board says he believes registration of the profession will not be pursued by ministers – at odds with a recommendation from an independent review.

People working in many other social care roles must register with the Scottish Social Services Council (SSSC) but PAs, who are directly contracted by people in receipt of self-directed support and/or the Independent Living Fund, are not required to do so.

The Independent Review of Inspection, Scrutiny and Regulation of Social Care in Scotland published last month recommends the development of a ‘co-produced and bespoke’ scheme of registration for PAs.

Such a scheme, says the review, would ‘expressly seek not to create barriers’ between PAs and their employer, but instead open up access to training and development.

However, the Chief Executive of Self-Directed Support (SDS) Scotland Donald Macleod says he believes Ministers will not pursue a register.

Mr Macleod, who also chairs the PA Programme Board – set up to improve the recognition of PAs within the social care workforce and recognise the important relationship between employers and their PA – says:

“We've continued to hear from employers and PAs that we engage with, that registration of PAs is not needed – and will put up additional barriers to employers seeking to recruit and retain PAs. 

"We understand the current position of the Scottish government is that that they will not pursue registration of PAs.”

The review, led by Dame Sue Bruce, says those responding to its call for views saw PA registration as an assurance that employers would receive safe and quality services.

It also heard that registration would ensure PAs can access training and resources not currently available to them.

However, the review also notes concerns from some respondents that PA registration could reduce the workforce and bring an intrusive regulation process into people’s homes.

This echoes fears raised by disabled activist and chair of the Scottish Independent Living Coalition (SILC), Dr Jim Elder-Woodward, around a lack of lived experience representative on the review panel and the review would see ‘mission ‘creep’ in the registration of PAs.

The review’s recommendations were published shortly after Donald Macleod told the SDS Scotland annual conference that concerns of PA regulation undermining the relationship, agency and control of the employer had been “well received” by the review team.

Mr Macleod, who sat on the review’s stakeholder engagement panel, said at the March conference that the review had taken a “separate focus” on PAs and would instead make “positive recommendations focused on improvement”.

The review states that it balanced the evidence it heard before it came to its conclusions.

Scotland’s Minister for Social Care, Mental Wellbeing and Sport, Maree Todd MSP, has told parliament she will consider the 38 recommendations in full before responding.

Donald Macleod says the PA Programme Board will continue to engage with the Scottish government around this issue, to ensure the voices of employers and PAs are heard during this process.